Learning about the First Thanksgiving Story with Printable Puppets

Written by Rebecca Reid

In anticipation of the upcoming holiday, we read The Very First Thanksgiving Day.  I made my preschool daughter a simple puppet template related to the traditional first Thanksgiving dinner with the Pilgrims and the Wampanoags. Although she is young, playing with First Thanksgiving Story Puppets is a nice start to understanding the meaning of the season as we imagine the historical event together.

Reading about The Very First Thanksgiving Day

The Very First Thanksgiving Day by Rhonda Gowler Greene shares the story of the Pilgrims with just the right number of words and bright, beautifully illustrated pages. As the playful cover illustration of children playing suggests, the pictures have a child-like innocent quality to them. That is not to diminish the facts of oppression to the Native Americans, which is a fact I don't want to be ignorant of, but rather a focus on the fact that for the children in Plymouth colony, there certainly were many reasons to celebrate and rejoice at that autumn harvest.

The text of the story loosely follows the pattern of "This is the house that Jack built," with subsequent pages repeating key elements from previous pages. Thus, by the end, we've heard a number of great details about the Pilgrim's travels and their delight at the fall harvest. I love the connections to children and regular old village life shown in the illustrations.

See this book on Amazon (affiliate link)

Making the First Thanksgiving Puppets

Our First Thanksgiving Puppets busy bag was pretty simple to create, using some basic tools and printing the puppets template on this page.

Here are the tools necessary:

I chose the cut out all the items and laminate them before assembling the dining table template. I guess you don't have to laminate them, but I did to prolong its life.

Then, I used the box cutter to cut slits where the puppet can "stand." I chose to do some slots on the hill and some in front of the table, so the people could walk up to the Thanksgiving gathering.

I used the hook-and-loop tape dots to put many options on the table and ground for where the food, baskets, and pitcher could be stored. Of course, the little pieces of food needed the other half of the dots.

For the people, I used some packing tape to attach them to the craft sticks. You could also use hot glue to attach them if they want too.

Why Puppets?

Frequently throughout modern history, the Wampanoag people have been disrespected during the holiday season. Children "act out" the first Thanksgiving, using incorrect food, incorrect terms for the people, and definitely incorrect costumes. We don't actually know what may have happened all those years ago, but we do know that the people who were already living in America had already been diminished by disease and were struggling to survive, much as the pilgrims who arrived in the new land were struggling to survive in their new home. 

Tradition tells us that as these two distinct groups worked together, they were able to have a successful and satisfying meal together. They were grateful to have food to enjoy during the harvest and thankful for their continued ability to stay alive! What a blessing that both groups were able to get along in this era, since in many eras of history they did not.

I feel that portraying this event through puppets with historically accurate clothing and food (to the best of my knowledge and ability) is a more fitting tribute to this feast of gratitude than acting with costumes would be for young children. I don't intend to diminish either group's heritage, and I also don't want to disrespect the tradition of giving thanks for a bountiful harvest and for food to sustain us. I feel portraying the people of the "first Thanksgiving" as puppets does an okay job of finding appropriate balance. 

Playing with the Puppets

By placing the puppets in front of the scene or by putting the craft sticks through the slits, you and your little one can talk about and imagine the yummy feast! The characters are children, again emphasizing that for the families gather, it was a time of rejoicing and being grateful for all blessings. Retelling familiar stories such as these with imagination play is an important skill for preschool-aged children to develop. So, even though it seems simple, don't underestimate the impact of imagination play and story retelling.

My daughter loves it. Even when it not yet Thanksgiving she'll pull out her Thanksgiving puppet "friends" to play with them. I think it is safe to say this is a great addition to our holiday "busy bag" this season.

Get a copy of the printable First Thanksgiving puppets when you sign up to become a Line upon Line Learning VIP.

You will get a password via email to get into the VIP Resource Library.

Already a VIP? Click over to the library and enter this month's password. I send a VIP email with the password every week!

Imagine the First Thanksgiving by retelling the story with these free printable puppets of Pilgrim and Indian (Wampanoag) children.

Like this post? Save it for later!

Related Articles:

Apple Busy Box Activities from Toddler to Kindergarten

Ah! Fall! The weather is not scheduled up in the 80s and 90s, and we can anticipate the crunch of falling leaves. Fall always reminds me of apple picking. I’m not sure we’re going this year, but it has been a frequent tradition for our family. To keep my little kids busy when I’m busy with

Read More

Introducing Pre-Colombian Native American Indians to Elementary Kids

Despite my best intentions, when I teach my year-long overview of American history, it is simply not possible to cover all the thousands of cultural groups that lived in America before the arrival of European explorers. It would take a year of study on its own! As a result, when I introduce my young kindergartner

Read More

An Introduction to U.S. Landforms with Paul Bunyan

Before we jump in to our lessons about American history, I wanted to make sure my daughter had a general understanding of the geography of the USA. The United States of America would be nothing without the land. Before we study the people who live here, we need to understand where “here” is! Our introduction to U.S.

Read More

Learn U.S. Geography with a Paper Mache USA

When I read Recipes for Play (reviewed on Rebecca Reads), I started feeling the urge to try something messy and drastically different. I saved some newsprint and bought paints. To learn about the geography of the United States, we made a three-dimensional paper mache model of the United States. I learned to let mess in, and

Read More

Learning about Native American Homes

I first wrote the booklet about early Native American homes because I could not find something simple for a brief introduction to Native Americans for my son. I wanted him to understand that there was a variety of cultures living on the American continent before Europeans arrived. I wanted him to understand that the vastness

Read More

A Memorable World Explorer Game for Two Players

To begin my hands-on American History class at my homeschool co-op, I decided to introduce the world explorers by playing our Guess Who?-inspired game: Guess the World Explorer! Not all of the kids knew details about the various world explorers, so we revisited the information cards to learn as we played.Setting up the World Explorers

Read More

Sign up to get Hands-On Learning Ideas in your inbox!